The Weight Problem

Every new performance car arrives with its power figure in bold. The weight turns up quietly in the technical data. It is the most important performance figure, and the one carmakers would least like to discuss.

Since 1986, the BMW M3 has put on roughly 530kg. That's about seven adults, and nobody launched that. Mass is the enemy of enjoyment, and for 20 years the industry has hidden its weight gain behind bigger and bigger power outputs. You use the power for a few seconds at a time. You carry the weight all day.

A small trap

There is no single kerb weight. The German DIN figure usually leaves the driver out. The European figure, called mass in running order, includes a fuel tank at least 90% full and a driver, rated by regulation at 75kg. So the same car can be quoted 75kg apart, depending on which figure suits the brochure.

Heavier, hidden by power

The original M3 of 1986 weighed about 1,200kg, according to BMW's heritage department. It made about 200 horsepower. By the V8 coupé, around 2007, BMW quoted 1,580kg and 420 horsepower. The current car, launched in 2020, is listed in BMW's own technical data at 1,730kg for the Competition, with 510 metric horsepower.

That's about 44% heavier, while power is up about two and a half times. On a spec sheet it looks like pure progress: roughly 295 horsepower per tonne against about 167.

But power to weight only improves in a straight line. It says nothing about how hard the front tyres work into a bend, how much heat the brakes soak up on a long descent, or how the car responds when you change direction. Extra power pays the weight bill in one place only, and it's the place you visit least.

The Golf GTI

Volkswagen's heritage material puts the first Golf GTI, from 1976, at around 800kg with 110 horsepower. Published data for the eighth generation car before its facelift, with the automatic gearbox, puts it at about 1,460kg on the DIN measure, with 245 horsepower. Same badge. Roughly 80% heavier.

In 2016 Volkswagen built the Golf GTI Clubsport S, a pared back special with 310 horsepower and, in Volkswagen's own words, "a kerb weight of just 1,286 kilos". It was limited to 400 cars. Lightness, it turns out, is a limited edition.

News when it falls, data when it rises

When BMW replaced the V8 M3 coupé with the M4 in 2014, its British press material announced in capital letters that the new coupé was under 1,500kg, and itemised the savings: 1,497kg against the old car's 1,580kg.

But the next M3 saloon, the current car, weighed around 185kg more than the one it replaced, on a like for like DIN basis. Try finding the headline for that one. Weight is news when it falls and data when it rises.

The case against

The strongest objection is safety. Modern cars carry deformable structures, side impact protection and airbag systems the originals didn't have. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety in America is blunt about the physics: in a collision, the heavier vehicle tends to keep moving forward and its occupants are subject to less force. A lighter vehicle, it concludes, will always be at a disadvantage against a heavier one.

Owners also asked for quieter cabins, more stable motorway manners and more equipment, all of which has mass. Then there are the batteries. Published data for BMW's electric i4 runs from about 2 tonnes to more than 2.2 tonnes. The combustion 4 Series Gran Coupé it shares a silhouette with is roughly 1,600 to 1,850kg. That's not laziness. That's chemistry.

The objection is fair. A modern M3 or GTI is far safer than its ancestor, and far easier to live with. Weigh enjoyment against your family's survival in a crash and weight wins, as it should.

Why the argument survives

But the protection from mass is relative, because a heavy car protects you partly by pushing the burden onto whoever you hit. If every car gains weight together, that advantage cancels out, leaving everyone with bigger brakes, wider tyres and higher running costs. It's an arms race. Good structure protects you whatever the other car weighs.

Yet BMW found more than 80kg to take out of an M car in 2014 without abandoning crash standards, and Volkswagen built a 1,286kg GTI in 2016. The engineering exists. What's missing is the priority.

Not all weight is a cover up. Some of it is a bill worth paying. The problem is the rest: the bigger footprint, the larger wheels, the extra drivetrain and features nobody asked for, fitted as standard. It gets waved through because another 50 horsepower will restore the acceleration figure, and acceleration is what gets printed in bold. Add weight, add power, print the power. Repeat.

A rule for reading the brochure

Weight is the figure you keep paying for long after the showroom: tyre bills, brake pads, fuel or electricity.

  1. Read the weight before the power.

  2. Check whether it's the DIN figure or the European one, and add or subtract 75kg so the comparison is honest.

  3. Ask whether this car needs its power, or just needs its power to hide its mass. If it's the second, the car is probably faster than it is fun.

What would change this view is evidence that the added weight has bought enjoyment, not just safety and silence. We haven't seen it. When weight comes out, the praise is for delicacy and response. When it goes in, the kindest word on offer is planted.

Weight is the most important performance figure, and manufacturers celebrate it only when it falls. Some of it bought our safety and has earned its place. The rest is drift, paid for with horsepower and billed to the driver. Power is what a car can do. Weight is what it has to carry whilst doing it.

This article comes from an episode of the Auto Culture Society Podcast. New episodes every Wednesday: the podcast.

Next
Next

Why Does Every New Car Look Angry?